Welcome to Gagliano's Pizza
Nestled in the heart of Lake Harmony, PA, Gagliano's Pizza is a culinary gem that brings a taste of authentic Italian cuisine right to the Poconos. With a commitment to quality, their menu features a variety of delectable offerings, from classic New York-style pizzas to mouthwatering sandwiches and freshly baked pastries. Locals rave about the thin crust pizzas, infused with rich flavors, all crafted with care by a Sicilian cook who knows the art of Italian cooking. Whether dining in or ordering takeout, Gagliano's guarantees a warm atmosphere and friendly service, making every meal a delightful experience.
-
2809 PA-903, Lake Harmony, PA 18624 Hotline: (570) 722-4686
Welcome to Gagliano's Pizza!
Located in the picturesque Lake Harmony, Pennsylvania, Gagliano's Pizza stands as a beacon of authentic Italian flavors nestled right off PA-903. Known for its comforting offerings of pizza, Italian cuisine, and hearty sandwiches, Gagliano's has become a staple for both locals and visitors alike. With a dedicated phone line at (570) 722-4686 and various dining options—from takeout to a cozy eat-in atmosphere—Gagliano's ensures that every guest feels right at home.
Set against the backdrop of the serene Pocono Mountains, Gagliano's is a must-visit for anyone craving a slice of New York style pizza. The reviews speak volumes, showcasing a consistent delight among patrons. One enthusiastic visitor, Ivan O., noted how Gagliano's pizza rivals even the best slices from Jersey, expressing mild regret for not ordering more than just two pies. Their pizzas—particularly the plain and the mushroom-pepper-sausage variety—have garnered rave reviews for their flavor and satisfying crust.
But Gagliano's isn't solely about pizza. Guests can indulge in Sicilian pies, which Dann M. discovered were fluffy, crispy, and cheesy, evoking a sense of authenticity that’s hard to find. If you have a sweet tooth, their selection of muffins, cinnamon buns, and assorted Danish pastries will certainly hit the spot.
Moreover, the customer service here shines just as brightly as the food. Many reviews highlight the friendly and attentive staff, making it a place where you’ll feel welcomed, whether you dine in or grab a quick bite. As Jennifer T. described, the variety doesn't end with pizza; subs, Philly cheesesteaks, and indulgent cannolis share the spotlight, inviting customers to explore the full range of Gagliano's culinary offerings.
- Signature Dishes: Thin-crust pizzas, fluffy Sicilian slices, and cheesy calzones.
- Must-Try Sides: Garlic knots and crispy fries.
- Desserts: Cannolis and assorted baked goods like muffins and Danish pastry.
- Beverages: A selection of bottled drinks, coffee, and refreshing juices.
For those planning a visit, be advised to arrive early on busy weekends, as Gagliano's tends to receive a steady influx of loyal patrons. With only a few dining tables available, you may want to take advantage of their quick and efficient takeout service.
In the end, Gagliano's Pizza shines as a culinary treasure in the Poconos. Whether you’re enjoying a classic slice or chatting with the owner about his Sicilian roots, the experience is bound to leave a lasting impression. Come for the food, stay for the warm hospitality, and leave with a desire to return—this spot is undoubtedly a slice of paradise for pizza enthusiasts!
Ordered delivery and wait time was estimated to be 2 hours but came closer to 1.5 hours. I ordered 2 large pizzas, fries, wings and it was the perfect amount for 6 people. The price wasn't too expensive and food was decent especially for the area. I think they could've gave more fries but overall a good experience.
got 2 pizzas, regretted it. only cause I only bought 2. as a north jersey head I was so disgusted by the fact that this pizza was so good all the way out in the poconos. def the place to go to if you want the comforts of a new york pizza in PA. I got a plain pizza and one with mushrooms, peppers, and sausage. order early on busy weekends bc theyll stop delivering like 2 hours early
I was in the area, so I stopped in. To my surprise they had a Sicilian pie! They don't make it every day, so I knew it was fresh. Boy was it good, fluffy, crispy and cheesy!
Great NY style pizza, subs, Philly cheesesteak, cannolis! As you can see we sampled as much as we could! Service was great!
I've tried several pizza shops in the Poconos, and Gagliano's is the best if you like thin crust with flavorful sauce and cheese. We've had takeout, but most recently we ate in on our way to Hickory Run. The server/counter staff was so friendly and helpful, and the food came out quickly. They only have a few tables for dining, and there was a steady stream of apparent regulars coming in for slices and takeout while we ate. The plain pizza was delicious, as were the garlic knots. Next time we're in the area, we'll stop at Gagliano's.
Better than NY pizza! Thin crispy slice and delicious. Friendly workers. Order ahead
This place was our quick stop for lunch and we loved it! We had cheese pizza and calzone. Pizza was delicious and calzone was full of cheese. Dough was perfect itself! We had a little chat with the cook/owner and he said he's from Sicily. So he knows how to make authentic Italian food. Kids 3 and 7 ate everything even the crust! I wish we ordered more to go!